I was thrilled to learn last week that one of Chicago’s own, Mindy Segal, was named Outstanding Pastry Chef by the James Beard Foundation after being nominated six times since 2007. She is the chef and owner of HotChocolate Restaurant & Dessert Bar, which just reopened this week after renovations as Mindy’s Hot Chocolate Craft Food & Drink. Photo (left) from Hot Chocolate’s website.
I interviewed Mindy a few months ago for a story about baking industry innovators in Modern Baking. (Read it here.) Admittedly, I was a little nervous. To me, she’s always been one of those larger-than-life figures in the culinary world–with vibrant dyed red hair, armfuls of tattoos and intensely flavorful, charred food and pastries.
I arrived at the restaurant on a mild January afternoon with that telltale reporter look: clutching my digital recorder and a few copies of the magazine, with the Canon digital camera slung over one shoulder and a large canvas bag over the other that was brimming with notes and PDFs of the menus.
“Excuse me, I’m here for an interview with Chef Segal,” I said. One of the servers directed me to a large booth overlooking the open-concept prep area. Just as I settled into my seat, Mindy burst out of the kitchen in a gray shirt with the sleeves rolled up, black pants and suspenders.
“Hi!” she gushed. “Sorry, it’s been crazy around here, since we’re about to start renovating the restaurant and I’m getting ready to leave for Dubai in a few days.”
“No problem,” I replied, as I fiddled with my recorder and dug out a pen. There are always a few anxious moments at the start of each interview, as you try to gauge what kind of personality your subject has and what they’ll be comfortable talking about.
We eased into the conversation, discussing her upcoming trip to Dubai and her 7-year-old restaurant/dessert bar. I asked her about balancing running a small business while hanging onto her pastry chef roots.
“I’m hardly in the kitchen anymore,” she lamented. “I mean, I’m in there almost everyday, rewriting menus and overseeing everything. I’ve evolved into a business owner, and I’m not so excited about it but it’s what I had to do. I’m 45 and can’t work 14 hours a day on my feet anymore. My life has changed. It was inevitable.”
She took me through a 10-minute slideshow on her iPhone of the different baked products and desserts she was working on, describing the items she was particularly excited about and still tweaking. Huge, pillowy English muffins, golden croissants, strudel and rugelach, oozing Danish and fresh bread wrapped in parchment and tied with twine.
“Send me two or three of those photos,” I said.

Giant English muffins, photo by Mindy Segal
We talked about the oft-misunderstood appeal of a lopsided cookie, a croissant with burnt edges or a pie crust made with bacon fat because goddamnit, that just makes for rustic and delicious pastries.
She described the many steps involved in composing her favorite desserts on the menu–each with its own personality, cultivated through various cooking techniques and careful layering of flavors and textures, like the housemade praline ice cream.
Hot Chocolate procures raw pecans from Three Sisters Garden in Kankakee, Ill. The pecans are boiled, salted, roasted and then cooked in a skillet with sugar and butter to make praline. That same skillet is deglazed with milk and cream; then egg yolks, vanilla and sugar are added to form crème anglaise (also known as ice cream base). Finally, the pecan praline is added to the crème anglaise, and the mixture is chilled. The final product gets plopped on top of Segal’s signature take on Québécoise sugar pie with bacon fat crust.
“When it comes to my food, I have a very quirky sense of humor that most people don’t get, but I do,” she said, wryly. “I do a lot with textures and temperatures. You’ll rarely get a dessert on my menu that’s one texture and one temperature.”

Fresh baked apple strudel, photo by Mindy Segal
We inevitably drifted into nerdy food talk, like the best method for rolling animal fat into flour to make pie crust, since it’s more unruly than cubed butter (chill it first, work quickly). Mindy scolded me for not yet having seen Mostly Martha, a German film about a controlling chef who gains custody of her headstrong niece and learns to lighten up. “It’s in my Netflix queue!” I insisted.
The conversation then strayed to Mindy’s upcoming wedding and all the planning and anxiety involved. Next thing I knew, I was confessing that the emotion of getting married plus the stress of throwing a party for 120 people was so intense that I didn’t shit for an entire week leading up to my own wedding.
I left Hot Chocolate a little before 6 that evening, face flushed from the rush of great conversation and belly full of sugar pie and praline ice cream (two scoops, not one, as she’d demonstrated to one of the pastry chefs as they prepared it for me side by side). I had finished most of the pie, ignoring the fact that I had to go home and prepare Guinness-braised beef for a few friends who were coming over an hour later.

My pre-dinner snack, with two scoops, not one
The next morning at work, I opened my inbox to see the following:
from: Mindy Segal
from: Mindy Segal
from: Mindy Segal
from: Mindy Segal
from: Mindy Segal
Each email contained a handful of photos that she had excitedly shown me on her phone the day before. I smiled, thinking of her trying to narrow down all those photos to just “two or three,” as I’d requested. A nearly impossible task when each was so lovingly created.
I later realized that the nerves I’d felt before interviewing one of my favorite chefs had been pointless. At the end of the day, it wasn’t a chef and a slightly starstruck food writer, it was just a couple of nerds trading stories and gushing over what makes truly great food. All we really want is to share our craft with someone who appreciates it.
Thanks, Mindy, for sharing your beautiful, imaginative food with all of us nerds.